top of page

Are Behavioral Assessments the Answer to all your Hiring Prayers? No. But They Will be the Answer to some of Them

Writer's picture: Harry LakinHarry Lakin

Behavioral Assessments Answer Some Hiring Prayers

The Scene: 


Another "can't miss" candidate has just quit after three months, leaving your TA team scrambling and your hiring budget shredded. It’s back to the drawing board!  You're wondering if there's a better way to predict success beyond polished resumes and rehearsed interviews. 


Enter behavioral assessments! They are not the answer to all hiring prayers, but they will answer some of them. Great assessments are an enterprise level tool that promises to decode candidate potential. But before you dive headfirst into the world of personality profiles and work style analyses, let's have an honest conversation about what these assessments can and cannot do.


Like an MRI, but for Hiring


Think of behavioral assessments as your hiring MRI, not your crystal ball.


Just as medical imaging helps doctors make more informed decisions without being the sole diagnostic tool, assessments offer valuable data points about how candidates should behave in real-world situations. They can reveal whether your ambitious sales candidate thrives under pressure or crumbles when it’s time to ask for the order. They might show that your potential project manager's collaborative style could clash with your team's existing dynamics.


The real power of behavioral assessments though, lies in their ability to uncover what traditional hiring methods often miss. While interviews can be masterfully performed by practiced candidates, and resumes expertly crafted to highlight strengths, behavioral assessments cut through the performance to reveal natural tendencies and working styles.


They're particularly valuable for identifying potential red flags that might not surface until months into the job – by which point you've already invested significant time and resources.

However, the implementation of these tools requires finesse. Many organizations fall into the trap of treating behavioral assessments as a pass/fail test, missing their true value as part of an overall evaluation strategy. The key is integration: using assessment insights to inform interview questions, guide reference discussions, and shape onboarding plans. When used this way, they become less about screening out candidates and more about understanding how to set them up for success.


Consider the case of technical roles, where traditional hiring often overemphasizes skills testing. A behavioral assessment might reveal that your highly skilled developer candidate struggles with ambiguity – crucial information if your workplace thrives on agile methodologies and rapid change. This insight doesn't necessarily disqualify the candidate, but it helps you make an informed decision and plan appropriate support structures if you proceed with the hire.


Look, behavioral assessments are not a magic bullet. They won't solve all your hiring challenges, but they will help you make better informed decisions. They won't eliminate all risk, but they will help you mitigate it better. The future of hiring isn't about finding a genie in a bottle – it's about building robust, multi-faceted processes that give us the best possible insight into potential talent. 


Behavioral assessments are an important piece of this puzzle, but remember: they're meant to enhance your hiring decisions, not make them for you.







 
 
 

Comments


Phoenix, AZ

480-825-1788

Austin, TX

512-240-2750

Proudly serving clients in: Austin | Dallas | Houston | Phoenix | Denver | Chicago | Bay Area | Los Angeles | San Diego | Seattle | Las Vegas | Santa Fe | Tucson

 

 

P.O. Box 30023, Phoenix, AZ  85046    |    Copyright © 2012-2024 by Hire Capacity, a part of HWL Consulting  

Organizational Management System and OMS are © 2002-2017 The Assessment and Development Group International Inc.

Privacy Policy

 

Back To Top

bottom of page